Exorcist 2 The Heretic (1977)
The Exorcist was always going to be a tough act to follow and hats off to John Boorman, who turned down the opportunity to direct the original, for at least attempting to make an original, compassionate, hopeful film, in the wake of William Friedkin’s colossus of the horror genre.
Exorcist 2, unfortunately, despite any initial good intentions from the filmmakers involved, has to rank as one of the most ill advised and ill executed sequels in cinematic history.
Set four years after the original ended, the film focuses on a burnt out exorcist called Father Lamont played by Richard Burton. Lamont is tasked by the church, following a rather rubbish attempt to exorcise a demon from a possessed young village girl which ends in self-immolation, to investigate the late Father Merrin, Max Von Sydow’s character from the original film, and his contentious final exorcism.
Cue lots of religious handwringing, ear-scrapingly awful dialogue, locust footage, Linda Blair tap dancing, more locust footage, James Earl Jones dressed as a locust, a giant demon locust, and one of the most unashamedly demented, noisy, nonsensical climaxes in film history, which features, yep, you guessed it, a plague of locusts.
One of the main problems with this utterly redundant, horror lite sequel (and there are many problems with it) is that it spends a lot of its time focusing on the psychological aftermath of Regan’s trauma, and offers nothing in the way of suspense or scares.
Ditching the escalating horrors, mystery and narrative courage of the original entirely, along with its thematic preoccupation with faith and motherhood under pressure, the film, which attempts to rationalise the experiences of Regan through the weird science manipulations of hypnosis and dream theory, fails quite spectacularly in almost all of its aspirations.
Instead, the film serves up a muddled and ludicrous metaphysical slurry devoid of emotional depth or anything remotely resembling narrative coherency. The film functions on the one hand as a kind of apology letter for the original movie, which John Boorman famously found distasteful and on the other, as a cack handed meditation on trauma and recovery.
Pitching the entrenched religious preoccupations of Burton’s cynical, hungover looking priest against the practical scientific burbling of modern day psychology the film disappears down a pseudo scientific rabbit hole and fails to resurface for most of its runtime.
Modern day psychology is represented by Louise Fletcher’s mildly patronising Dr. Gene Tuscin who via the use of a synchronising hypnosis science fiction gadget straight out of the mad professor playbook, gets Regan to relive her trauma for no discernible therapeutic reason whatsoever.
Fletcher woodenly plays a watered down version of the terrifying Nurse Ratchet character she played in One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest but hers is not even the worst performance in the film. Richard Burton makes absolutely no use of his prodigious talents whatsoever, as self hating demon obsessed Lamont, who stumbles from one ennui inducing dramatic interlude to another, in a befuddled attempt to unravel the mystery of Pazuzu.
Linda Blair makes the best of a bad job, having been cast as a gee whizz golly gosh spiritual healer in training for sainthood, hobbled by her previous history of demonic possession. However, there is no way to make tap dancing Regan look anything other than silly and especially in the film’s climactic episode with a locust dangling out of her nose when she decides to pirouette on a make belief stage as a way of ridding herself of her inner demons.
Technically the film is competently shot, though the periodically intriguing visuals from DP William A. Fraker, don’t compensate for the meandering script, and the film’s complete lack of focus.
The film also features an interesting, dreamy score from Ennio Morricone, who really does make a grand effort to infuse events with a bit of drama but fails mostly due to how utterly nonsensical the film is.
Fails on almost every level then, but worth watching if you’re a Boorman completist or if you just want to see what a truly spectacular swing and miss cinematic failure looks like.


